Rachel (missfreud) wrote in chem_haters,

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Fake sugar

So my chem professor has this thing he calls "Cool Molecule of the Week (CMOTW)," for which he takes a few minutes of lecture-time every week to talk about a random molecule. Now, of course everyone likes these because they're welcome diversions, usually somewhat applicable to real life, and not on exams. ;) CMOTW this quarter has featured ascorbic acid (which Linus Pauling apparently took tons of) and anabolic steroids (the professor spent half the time talking about how much Barry Bonds must have taken), and this week the molecules were artificial sweeteners.

Saccharin (the stuff in pink packets):

Supposedly saccharin was found to be carcinogenic in lab rats, in particular causing bladder cancer, but harmless to humans because rats concentrate their urine a lot more than we do, but my professor says, 'so what if someday our kidneys decide to concentrate our urine more" (perhaps because of excessive salt intake)? So he doesn't touch this stuff.

Splenda (the new stuff in yellow packets):

Compare to sucrose, from which it is derived:

So Splenda (sucrolose) is sucrose with 3 OH groups replaced by Cl's. My professor says, in a very chemistry-professor sort of way, something like "Now see how easy it is to have a nucleophile attack and displace chloride, a good leaving group. I don't want this sort of thing happening in my body. I use 0 Splenda."

Nutrasweet (the stuff in blue packets):

Basically just a dipeptide formed with aspartic acid at the N-terminus and phenylalanine at the C-terminus. Now my chem professor, who drinks like 5 bottles of Diet Pepsi a day, insists that Nutrasweet is completely harmless since it can only be broken down into naturally occuring amino acids, and that drinking it is "just like eating steak." My neuroscience professor would beg to differ. Aspartic acid is structurally similar to glutamic acid, a neurotransmitter that, when present in excess, can be excitotoxic and cause neuron death. When taken orally, excessive intake of these two amino acids could kill neurons in areas of the brain not protected by the blood brain barrier, making the young particularly susceptible. So taking too much Nutrasweet is basically the same as having too much MSG. Now, drinking diet soda and eating out at Chinese restaurants once in a while probably won't really have enough of an effect, but if you drink a gallon of diet soda every day... I wonder if I should tell my chem professor that.

So the take-home lesson, I guess, is that all artifical sweeteners present some sort of health danger. And that synthetic chemicals are bad. Ha.
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.